Why a payment institution cannot call itself a bank, and why you should care
Only licensed banks may call themselves a bank or take deposits. Learn what a balance at a payment institution really is and how safeguarding protects it.

Key takeaways
- In Singapore, only licensed banks may call themselves a bank, and only banks may take deposits. A payment app is banned from using those words.
- A balance at a payment institution isn’t a deposit but a claim on the institution, backed by safeguarding arrangements that the law requires.
- Deposit insurance pays out a capped amount quickly when a bank fails, while safeguarded money comes back through the safeguarding arrangement, often after an insolvency process, which can take years if the firm’s records are poor.
- Singapore caps personal e-wallets at SGD $20,000.
A word reserved by law
Open almost any payment app and you’ll notice the same careful wording.
- Your money sits in a “wallet”,
- you “top up” instead of making a deposit,
- and the app shows you a “balance” rather than “savings”.
Much of that is deliberate. In Singapore, the Banking Act reserves the word “bank”, along with its derivatives in any language, for licensed banks. On top of that, it restricts who is allowed to take or ask for deposits.
Real case: Singapore isn’t the only place where regulators take this seriously. In 2021, the US fintech app Chime agreed with California’s financial regulator to stop using the web address chimebank.com, as Chime itself doesn’t hold a banking licence. Illinois reached a similar settlement and added a $200,000 penalty. Interestingly, Chime’s customers did have deposit accounts, but those accounts sat at Chime’s partner banks. The only issue in the eyes of the regulators was that a company which wasn’t a bank was advertising itself as one.
So why does one word matter this much? Because “bank” tells you that the firm itself is licensed, supervised and capitalised as a bank, and that your balance is a deposit, usually backed by a public insurance scheme up to a certain limit. Banks, ever since the financial crisis of 2008, go through extremely strict regulation, forcing them to maintain more than enough cash to ensure liquidity and solvency.
A payment institution hasn’t had to do any of that, so allowing those firms to market themselves as a bank would be unfair competition. Furthermore, once things do go wrong, the distinction does make a difference for you as a client.
What makes a bank a bank
A bank does two things that a payment institution doesn’t:
- it takes deposits,
- and it uses them to fund loans.
Singapore’s Banking Act defines banking business as receiving money on current or deposit account, paying and collecting cheques, and making advances (meaning loans) to customers.
Lending is the heart of the business model without which a bank could or should not be able to make money. The bank pays savers one interest rate, charges borrowers a higher one and keeps the difference. This also means that, legally, your balance at a bank is a debt the bank owes you, at least in common-law systems such as Singapore’s and the UK’s. In other words, you’ve lent the bank your money and they are indebted to you.
Because that model puts customer money at risk, banks face the heaviest rules in finance:
- capital requirements,
- liquidity buffers
- and deposit insurance.
A payment institution works under a different licence. In Singapore, a major payment institution licensed under the Payment Services Act can:
- issue payment accounts and e-money,
- and move money at home and across borders, depending on which services its licence covers.
However, it can’t take deposits, and an e-money issuer isn’t allowed to lend customers money.
Instead, that money has to be safeguarded.
What you actually own
Let’s start with the most important point: a balance at a payment institution is not a deposit.
Singapore’s Payment Services Act defines e-money as stored value that represents a claim on its issuer, and explicitly excludes deposits from that definition. EU law draws the same line. Money you hand to an e-money institution has to be exchanged for e-money without delay, and it doesn’t count as a deposit.
So what do you actually hold? A claim on the institution, which is essentially its promise to pay you back on demand. That promise is backed by the safeguarding arrangements the institution must have in place, and how strong that promise is really depends on the strength of the regulation the institution is subjected to.
Real case: Let’s look at the UK case of ipagoo to show how much those rules matter. When this e-money institution collapsed, the Court of Appeal ruled that customer money wasn’t held in a trust, meaning it didn’t legally belong to the customers. They were creditors of the firm instead. The good news is that they were first in line, ahead of every other creditor, and that any money the firm should have set aside but hadn’t had to be made up from its other assets.
In practice, though, customers still had to wait for the administrator to work out who was owed what, and if a firm’s assets fall short, nobody gets paid in full. Singapore’s rules differ here, as the Payment Services Act explicitly allows safeguarding through an undertaking, a guarantee or a trust account.
This status also has side effects you can see in the app itself. In the EU, e-money issuers aren’t allowed to pay interest, or any other benefit linked to how long you hold the balance. In fact, the European Commission ties that ban directly to e-money not being a deposit. In Singapore, the economics point the same way: an e-money issuer can’t lend customer money on, so it lacks the lending income a bank uses to pay interest in the first place.
Two safety nets, built differently
Both banks and payment institutions protect customer money, but they use different tools to do so.
Deposit insurance
- The Singapore Deposit Insurance Corporation (SDIC) covers up to SGD $100,000 per depositor at each member bank or finance company.
- In the EU, deposit guarantee schemes cover eligible deposits up to €100,000 per person per institution.
Neither of them covers e-money.
Even at a bank, there’s a catch. SDIC only covers Singapore-dollar deposits, and in 2023 MAS decided not to extend it to foreign currencies, arguing that small depositors mostly save in Singapore dollars anyway. This means that a US dollar or euro balance at a Singapore bank falls outside the protection.
Safeguarding
A major payment institution has to safeguard customer money instead. Under the Payment Services Act, it can do this through an undertaking from a safeguarding institution (typically a bank) to be liable for the amount, through a guarantee from such an institution, or by holding the money in a trust account.
In practice, trust accounts and guarantees are used less often because they are more complicated to set up and run, so many firms rely on an undertaking. Where a trust account is used, the money is kept apart from the firm’s own funds, so it can’t be used to pay the firm’s other creditors.
That said, safeguarding has weak spots of its own. With an undertaking, customers depend on the safeguarding institution honouring its promise, so the strength of that institution matters. Where a trust account is used, the money is usually pooled with other customers’ money, so after a failure, someone first has to work out who owns what. And if the bank holding the trust account fails, customers may have to wait longer to get their money back, or may not recover all of it.
| Balance at a bank | Balance at a payment institution | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal status | Deposit (a debt the bank owes you) | Claim on the institution, backed by safeguarding arrangements |
| What the provider does with it | Uses it to fund loans | Safeguards it; e-money may not be lent on |
| Protection if the provider fails | Deposit insurance, up to a cap (in Singapore: SGD $100,000, Singapore-dollar deposits only) | Safeguarding arrangement pays out, often after an insolvency process |
| Interest | Possible | Banned on e-money in the EU |
When it goes wrong
This is where the difference really shows.
- A deposit insurance scheme is built to pay out a capped amount quickly.
- Safeguarded money, on the other hand, only comes back once the safeguarding arrangement has paid out.
Where a trust account is involved, that also means waiting until an insolvency practitioner has worked out which funds belong to which customer, and that can take far longer. With an undertaking, customers rely on the safeguarding institution to honour its promise.
Real case: On top of that, safeguarding only works if the firm actually did it properly. The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority looked at the 12 payment firms that became insolvent between early 2018 and mid-2023. On average, the money they had safeguarded fell 65% short of what they owed customers, and for e-money institutions alone, the gap was as large as 80%. Where there was money to hand back, customers waited an average of 2.3 years to receive it.
The 2024 collapse of Synapse, a US middleware firm sitting between fintech apps and their partner banks, shows the same problem from a different angle. Synapse wasn’t a licensed payment institution, but it kept the records for more than 100,000 customer accounts. When it failed, more than US$265 million was frozen, and customers lost access to an estimated US$60–90 million that couldn’t be traced back to them.
More than a year later, much of it still hadn’t been recovered. What makes this case interesting is that the money sat at insured banks, yet deposit insurance didn’t help at all. It only pays out when a bank fails, and in this case, no bank had.
So does this mean payment institutions are unsafe? Not by default. What both cases do show is that safeguarding is only as good as the records behind it, and that customers of a failed firm have to wait for the safeguarding arrangement to be settled rather than receive a fixed payout.
Why Singapore caps personal e-wallets
Singapore also limits how much a Singaporean individual can keep in an e-wallet. Since 15 December 2023, a personal e-wallet issued by a major payment institution can hold at most SGD $20,000 at any given time, and send out at most SGD $100,000 over a rolling 12-month period.
Keep in mind that these are ceilings, so providers are free to set lower ones.
Transfers to a bank account in your own name, or one you’ve designated, don’t count towards that outflow cap. Providers that adopt the higher caps are also expected by MAS to put anti-scam measures in place, such as a default limit of SGD $1,000 per outgoing transaction (which users can choose to raise).
In practice, this keeps personal e-wallet balances at the size of everyday money: the salary that comes in and the bills that go out. They simply aren’t designed for long-term savings. It’s also worth noting that these caps only apply to personal e-wallets, not to business accounts.
How to check what you’re dealing with
- Look the firm up in the regulator’s register. In Singapore, that’s the MAS Financial Institutions Directory, and in the EU, it’s the EBA’s central register of payment and e-money institutions. The licence type tells you whether you’re holding a deposit or a payment balance.
- Read the safeguarding disclosure. Licensed payment institutions usually explain how they safeguard customer money and which risks remain.
- Ask how the money is safeguarded. Is it through an undertaking, a guarantee or a trust account? Which institution stands behind it? And in which currency?
- Match the provider to the job. A payment institution is built to move, hold and convert money. If you have large savings you won’t touch for years, consider keeping them somewhere deposit insurance applies, and check that the currency is covered too.
- Watch the words. If a firm calls itself a bank, or calls your balance a deposit, it should hold the licence to back that up.
FAQ
Is e-money covered by deposit insurance in Singapore?
No. SDIC covers Singapore-dollar deposits at member banks and finance companies, up to SGD $100,000 per depositor per member. A balance at a payment institution is protected by safeguarding instead.
Why doesn’t my wallet balance earn interest?
Because it isn’t a deposit. A bank can pay interest because it lends your money on, while an e-money issuer isn’t allowed to provide loans and has to safeguard the money instead. In the EU, the law goes one step further and bans interest on e-money outright.
What happens to my money if a payment institution fails?
How your money comes back depends on the safeguarding method. With a trust account, the funds are kept apart from the firm’s own money and returned by an insolvency practitioner. With an undertaking or a guarantee, the safeguarding institution is liable for the amount. Either way, the process is usually slower than a deposit insurance payout, and how much you get back depends on whether the firm safeguarded everything it should have.
What is the difference between a bank and a payment institution?
A bank takes deposits, uses them to fund loans and is covered by deposit insurance. A payment institution moves, holds and converts money, and protects customer balances through safeguarding.
About Walletory
Walletory Pte. Ltd. is licensed as a major payment institution by the Monetary Authority of Singapore under the Payment Services Act 2019 (licence No. PS20200579). It is not a bank, and it safeguards customer money through an undertaking from a safeguarding institution in Singapore.
Disclaimer
This article is published by Walletory Pte. Ltd. (“Walletory”) for general information and illustrative purposes only. It is intended to provide general explanation related to the industry and its functioning and does not describe, promote, or constitute an offer of any product or service provided by Walletory.
The content does not constitute legal, financial, tax, investment, or other professional advice, and should not be relied upon as such. Readers should seek independent professional advice before making any decision based on information contained in this article. Walletory Pte. Ltd. makes no warranty as to its accuracy or completeness and, to the fullest extent permitted by law, accepts no liability for any reliance placed on it.
Sources
- Singapore Statutes Online: Banking Act 1970
- MAS: Payment Services Act 2019
- Clifford Chance: Singapore Parliament passes Payment Services Bill (January 2019, PDF)
- Withers: A quick guide to Singapore’s payment services ecosystem (June 2022)
- EBA: Single Rulebook Q&A 2022_6421 on e-money, deposits and interest
- CMS: Increase in insurance coverage for Singapore-dollar bank deposits to SGD 100,000
- Allen & Gledhill: MAS raises stock cap and flow cap on personal e-wallets (January 2024)
- Shook Lin & Bok: MAS circular on anti-scam measures for e-wallet providers (November 2024)
- Linklaters: How are e-money holders protected on insolvency? Court of Appeal decision on ipagoo (March 2022)
- DLA Piper: FCA payments and e-money safeguarding consultation (October 2024)
- Ballard Spahr via Mondaq: CFPB files complaint against Synapse Financial Technologies (September 2025)
- CeFPro: CFPB hunts missing USD 90M in Synapse collapse fallout (August 2025)
- Consumer Financial Services Law Monitor: Chime Financial fintech cannot claim it is a bank (May 2021)
- Baird Holm: Whose “bank” is it anyway? State enforcement actions against Chime (May 2021)


